Authentic New York Club Sandwich Recipe
A classic New York club sandwich is one of those timeless diner favorites that never goes out of style. Tender roasted turkey, crisp bacon, fresh lettuce, juicy tomato, and creamy mayonnaise are stacked between three slices of perfectly toasted bread to create a hearty sandwich that’s just as satisfying today as it was decades ago.
Perfectly stacked and timeless
I first learned to make New York club sandwiches while working in a diner back in 1980. Over the next 45 years of my career in the restaurant industry, I made countless club sandwiches, because they were one of the most popular items on nearly every diner menu I worked with.
I still make them at home for friends and family because they come together so easily, and they always spark memories of sitting in an old-school diner booth, waiting for that craveworthy towering sandwich to arrive with a pile of potato chips and a dill pickle spear on the side.
If you want to recreate an authentic diner-style club sandwich at home, this recipe will show you exactly how to build it the classic way, with the proper layering, generous fillings, and crisp toasted bread that have made this sandwich a diner classic for generations.
Bring more diner favorites to your table with my turkey bacon cheese melt sandwich, grilled tuna melt sandwich, and grilled BBQ chicken melt.
Who created this iconic sandwich?
The exact origin of the club sandwich is uncertain, but one of the earliest widely cited published references appeared in the New York newspaper The Evening World in 1889. It described a Union Club sandwich made with two slices of toasted graham bread and a layer of turkey or chicken and ham, served warm. Although it is not known whether the sandwich was actually created there.
Another long-standing claim credits the Saratoga Club House in Saratoga Springs, New York, during the 1890s. By the early 1900s, the club sandwich had become recognizable as the stacked sandwich served on toasted bread with poultry, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, but the historical record does not establish exactly when the third slice of bread became standard.
Recipe ingredients
- Pullman bread: Choose a square Pullman loaf for the most authentic New York club sandwich. Its straight sides create even layers that stack neatly and make it easy to cut the finished sandwich into four uniform triangles. If you’d rather bake your own bread, my artisan rye bread from scratch, rustic whole wheat bread, and from scratch no knead bread are all excellent choices. Because they’re baked as artisan loaves rather than in square Pullman pans, your sandwich won’t have the traditional square shape, so you’ll need to adjust how you cut and serve it.
- Turkey breast: Roasted deli turkey breast is the traditional choice for a New York club sandwich. Have it sliced to a medium thickness so it creates hearty layers without making the sandwich difficult to stack and eat.
- Bacon: Thick-cut bacon provides the best texture and stands up well to the generous layers of turkey and toast. Cook it until crisp so it adds a satisfying crunch without becoming so brittle that it breaks apart when you bite into the sandwich.
- Mayonnaise: A rich, full-flavored mayonnaise is essential because it’s one of the sandwich’s primary components, not just a spread. My creamy homemade mayo is an excellent choice for its fresh flavor and rich texture.
See the recipe card for full information on ingredients and quantities.
Make it your own
- Switch the protein: Ham, roast beef, pastrami, tuna salad, any of my homemade chicken salads—including my classic chicken salad recipe, homemade spicy chicken salad, and chicken salad with fresh basil — or simple homemade egg salad all make excellent alternatives to turkey. Choose a filling that slices or spreads neatly so the sandwich stays stable and is easy to cut into quarters.
- Add cheese: While it isn’t traditional, sliced cheddar, Swiss, provolone, gouda, or American cheese adds another layer of rich flavor and pairs well with the turkey and bacon.
- Make it California-style: Add thinly sliced avocado or red onion for a West Coast style twist. It’s a variation I first came across while living in California, and it’s still one I enjoy today.
- Simplify it: Skip the middle slice of bread and build the sandwich with two slices of toast instead. It won’t be a traditional club sandwich, but it’s easier to eat and is often served in diners as a turkey BLT.
How to make a New York club sandwich
The secret to building a classic New York club sandwich is layering the ingredients evenly so each quarter stays together after it’s cut. Following the traditional order of the fillings also helps create a balanced bite with turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and toast in every piece.
Step 1: Toast three slices of Pullman bread until golden brown. Spread a thin, even layer of mayonnaise on one side of each slice.
Step 2: Place one slice of toast, mayonnaise-side up, on your work surface. Layer with half of the turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato, arranging the ingredients evenly from edge to edge so each quarter of the sandwich has a balanced filling.
Step 3: Place the second slice of toast over the fillings, mayonnaise-side down. Spread mayonnaise over the top of that slice, then repeat the layers with the remaining turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Step 4: Finish with the third slice of toast, mayonnaise-side down. Gently press the sandwich together to keep the layers aligned. Insert frill picks into each quarter before cutting, then use a sharp serrated knife to slice diagonally in both directions, creating four triangles.
Top tips
- Toast the bread: A traditional New York club sandwich is served on toasted bread in diners because the crisp texture complements the fillings and provides better structure for the stacked layers. While you can use untoasted bread, the sandwich won’t have the same classic texture.
- Toast to a light golden brown: The bread should be crisp enough to support the layers but still tender enough to bite through comfortably. Overtoasted bread can make the sandwich difficult to eat.
- Cut the bacon before cooking: Halving the bacon strips before they go into the pan helps them fit the bread neatly and makes it easier to distribute them evenly across each layer.
- Fold the lettuce to fit the bread: Fold each lettuce leaf into a square about the same size as the Pullman bread, then gently press it flat with your hand before layering it onto the sandwich. This creates an even layer and helps keep the fillings from shifting as you stack and slice.
- Slice the tomatoes evenly: Cut the tomatoes into slices of a consistent thickness so each layer stays level and every quarter of the sandwich has a balanced bite.
- Don’t overload the layers: Resist the temptation to pile on extra fillings. A properly proportioned club sandwich is easier to cut, stays together better, and gives you the right balance of turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and toast in every bite.
- Steady the sandwich while slicing: After inserting the frill picks, place one hand gently over the top of the sandwich to keep the layers aligned while cutting with a sharp serrated knife. Use a gentle sawing motion instead of pressing straight down to produce clean quarters without crushing the sandwich.
- Expect a little mess: A generously filled club sandwich isn’t meant to stay perfectly intact. Insert the frill picks before slicing to help hold the layers together while you cut it into quarters. Once it’s served, remove the picks before eating and enjoy it knowing that a little shifting of the fillings is part of what makes a great club sandwich.
- Serve immediately: This sandwich is at its best as soon as it’s assembled. Waiting too long allows the toast to soften and the crisp textures to fade, so assemble it just before serving for the best flavor and texture.
Serve
A New York club sandwich is traditionally served with crisp potato chips and a dill pickle spear, and many diners also add a side of creamy classic farmhouse coleslaw. If you’re in the mood for a heartier meal, swap the chips for homemade hand-cut French fries or upgrade them to garlic Asiago potato wedges. For picnics, lunches, or casual dinners, a scoop of from-scratch potato salad is another delicious side that pairs perfectly with this classic diner sandwich.
Other recipes you’ll love
If you loved this sandwich recipe, give these other great sandwich recipes a try too!
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Crispy Buffalo Chicken Sliders (Bold & Spicy)
Loose Meat Sliders (Midwestern Style Ground Beef Sandwich)
Grilled Teriyaki Chicken Sliders (Bold & Juicy)
Easy Green Apple Grilled Cheese
Ground Beef Stroganoff Sandwich
New York Club Sandwich
Ingredients
- 3 slices Pullman bread
- 2 tablespoons mayonnaise
- 6 oz sliced deli turkey
- 3 slices bacon cooked
- 4 slices tomato
- 2 leaves iceberg lettuce
Instructions
- Toast the Pullman bread until lightly golden brown. Spread a thin, even layer of mayonnaise over one side of each slice.
- Place one slice of toast, mayonnaise-side up, on a cutting board. Layer with half of the turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
- Top with the second slice of toast, mayonnaise-side down. Spread mayonnaise over the top of the second slice, then layer with the remaining turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
- Finish with the third slice of toast, mayonnaise-side down. Press the sandwich together gently to align the layers.
- Insert frill picks into each quarter of the sandwich. Using a sharp serrated knife, cut diagonally in both directions to create four triangles.
- Serve immediately with potato chips, a dill pickle spear, and coleslaw, if desired.
Notes
- Toasted Pullman bread provides the traditional shape and texture, but any sturdy sandwich bread can be used.
- Assemble the sandwich just before serving for the best texture. The toast will soften if made too far in advance.
- Frill picks help hold the layers together while cutting and serving the sandwich.
- Slice with a sharp serrated knife using a gentle sawing motion for the cleanest cuts.
- This recipe is easily scaled for serving a crowd.
Nutrition
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.
Would you like to save this post for later?
We'll email it to you, so you can come back to it whenever you like!
There’s nothing quite like a Classic New York Club Sandwich — layered just right with crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, and perfectly cooked bacon and turkey. It’s a timeless favorite that always hits the spot! If you try building your own version at home, I’d love to hear how it turned out. Feel free to leave a comment with your favorite add-ons or any questions you might have. Enjoy every delicious layer!